Criminal Justice (Mutual Assistance) Act 2008

60E

F62[Refusal to execute external financial penalty order

60E. (1) On application made under section 60D(2) and without prejudice to section 3, the appropriate court shall make an order refusing the execution of an external financial penalty order made by an issuing judicial authority if

(a) a financial penalty order has been made in the State against the defendant in respect of the conduct which resulted in the making of the external financial penalty order,

(b) a financial penalty order has been made in a state other than the issuing state or the State, in respect of the conduct which resulted in the making of the external financial penalty order, and has been executed,

(c) the conduct which resulted in the making of the external financial penalty order is not an offence in the State,

(d) the execution of the financial penalty order is statute barred in the State,

(e) the criminal conduct concerned was either committed outside the territory of the issuing state concerned or committed wholly or partly in the State,

(f) there is immunity or privilege under the law of the State which makes it impossible to execute the external financial penalty order,

(g) the defendant could not have been convicted in the State of an offence in respect of the conduct which resulted in the making of the external financial penalty order because of his or her age,

(h) the defendant did not appear in person at the proceedings resulting in the external financial penalty order, unless the certificate from the issuing judicial authority states that

(i) he or she was summonsed to attend in person the proceedings, or he or she was otherwise made aware, by official notification, of the time when, and the place at which, those proceedings were to take place, and he or she was informed that an external financial penalty order could be made even if he or she did not appear,

(ii) he or she was aware of the proceedings concerned and was represented at those proceedings by a lawyer whom he or she appointed,

(iii) after having been served with the external financial penalty order and expressly informed of his or her right to a retrial or an appeal at which he or she would have been able to participate (and which would have been an examination of the case on its merits, including the possibility of adducing fresh evidence), and which could have led to a reversal of the original decision, he or she

(I) expressly stated that he or she did not contest the external financial penalty order, or

(II) did not request the retrial or appeal within the time limit for exercising that right,

or

(iv) where he or she was not personally served with the external financial penalty order, an undertaking has been given by the issuing state concerned that he or she will be personally served with the external financial penalty order without delay and will be expressly informed of his or her right to a retrial or an appeal in which he or she will be able to participate (and which will be an examination of the case on its merits, including the possibility of adducing fresh evidence), and which could lead to a reversal of the order, and of the time limit for exercising that right,

or

(i) the amount of the financial penalty the subject of the external financial penalty order is less than 70.

(2) If the certificate did not accompany the external financial penalty order, or is incomplete or manifestly does not correspond to the external financial penalty order, the appropriate court

(a) may permit the certificate, or a completed or corrected certificate, to be produced by or on behalf of the court concerned in accordance with a specified deadline, or

(b) may refuse to execute the external financial penalty order, unless it is satisfied, by the production of an equivalent document or otherwise, that the information provided by or on behalf of the court concerned is sufficient.]

Annotations

Amendments:

F62

Inserted (23.09.2019) by Criminal Justice (Mutual Assistance) (Amendment) Act 2015 (40/2016), s. 24, S.I. No. 468 of 2019.