Civil Liability and Courts Act 2004

Defence and counterclaim.

12

12.—(1) A defence to a personal injuries action shall specify—

(a) the allegations specified, or matters pleaded, in the personal injuries summons of which the defendant does not require proof,

(b) the allegations specified, or matters pleaded in the personal injuries summons of which he or she requires proof,

(c) the grounds upon which the defendant claims that he or she is not liable for any injuries suffered by the plaintiff, and

(d) where the defendant alleges that some or all of the personal injuries suffered by the plaintiff were occasioned in whole or in part by the plaintiff's own acts, the grounds upon which he or she so alleges.

(2) A counterclaim in a personal injuries action shall specify—

(a) the personal public service number allocated and issued to the defendant under section 223 (inserted by section 14 of the Act of 1998) of the Act of 1993,

(b) the injuries to the defendant alleged to have been occasioned by the wrong of the plaintiff,

(c) full particulars of all items of special damage in respect of which the defendant is making a claim,

(d) full particulars of the acts of the plaintiff constituting the said wrong and the circumstances relating to the commission of the said wrong,

(e) full particulars of each instance of negligence by the plaintiff.

(3) Where a defendant fails to comply with this section—

(a) the court may—

(i) direct that the action shall not proceed further until the defendant complies with such conditions as the court may specify, or

(ii) where it considers that the interests of justice so require, give judgment in favour of the plaintiff,

and

(b) the court shall take such failure or refusal into account when deciding whether to make any order as to the payment of the costs of the personal injuries action concerned, or the amount of such costs.

(4) Where a defendant fails to comply with this section, the court hearing the personal injuries action concerned may draw such inferences from the failure as appear proper.

Annotations

Modifications (not altering text):

C5

For purposes of certain proceedings, section to be construed as provided (10.04.2023) by Garda Síochána (Compensation) Act 2022 (33/2022), s. 24(2)(e), S.I. No. 163 of 2023.

Additional provisions regarding proceedings

24. (1) The proceedings referred to in section 23 shall, subject to this Act and the Act of 2003 as applied by section 19 and with any necessary modifications, be deemed to be a personal injuries action for the purposes of any enactments relating in whole or in part to personal injuries actions (including the Act of 2004) and shall be treated as if they were a personal injuries action within the meaning of those enactments, including for the purposes of costs.

(2) Notwithstanding subsection (1), the Act of 2004 shall apply to the proceedings referred to in section 23 with the following modifications: ...

(e) section 12 of the Act of 2004 shall be read as if the words “personal injuries summons” were the words “Garda compensation personal injuries summons”, wherever they occur;

...